Policy Risk & Tether Audit Drive Circle’s Selloff, COIN May Offer Better RV, HYPE Continues to Decouple

Note: As part of our transition from FS Insight to Fundstrat Direct, my notes will transition from sean.farrell@fsinsight.com to sean.farrell@fundstratdirect.com. Please add the new address to your contacts or safe sender list to ensure uninterrupted delivery. The research and insights you rely on will remain exactly the same — only our name and sender address are changing. If you have questions, please visit our FAQ here.

Discussed in today’s video:

  • Stablecoin Yield Language Update: Reports suggest the latest Clarity Act proposal would restrict platforms from offering yield on stablecoins in a manner resembling deposits. This aligns with prior OCC guidance and signals the banking lobby may be prevailing on this issue. While details remain fluid, the market is beginning to price in constraints on yield-driven user acquisition.
  • Circle Hit by Dual Headwinds: Circle’s sharp drawdown likely reflects both regulatory uncertainty and rising competitive pressure from Tether. Yield restrictions could slow USDC growth at the margin, particularly if yield is no longer a viable distribution lever. More importantly, Tether’s move toward a full Big Four audit signals a credible push into U.S. markets, raising the risk of market share loss.
  • Tether Audit a Structural Inflection Point: Tether’s engagement with a major accounting firm for a full audit is a meaningful step toward institutional legitimacy. This could materially improve trust among U.S. investors and accelerate onshore adoption. If successful, it represents a structural competitive threat to Circle, which already operates with thinner margins.
  • Coinbase Selloff Looks Overdone on a Relative Basis: The move lower in Coinbase likely reflects concerns around reduced USDC-related monetization. However, historical data suggests limited correlation between USDC supply growth and Coinbase trading volumes, which are more directly tied to price action.
  • Relative Value Setup Improving (COIN vs. CRCL): The Coinbase-Circle dynamic may continue to shift in Coinbase’s favor. Coinbase is likely to retain its economic relationship with Circle, while Circle faces increasing competitive pressure and fewer growth levers. The current dislocation suggests potential for relative outperformance in Coinbase.
  • Market Backdrop Still Fragile Despite Late Bounce: Broader crypto price action remains under pressure, with recent underperformance versus equities and persistent macro overhangs. While headlines around a potential ceasefire are driving a post-close bounce, confirmation remains limited, and conviction in a durable shift is low.
  • Differentiated Strength in Hyperliquid (HYPE): HYPE continues to stand out, demonstrating both absolute and relative strength alongside low correlation to BTC. With ongoing traction across both crypto-native and exogenous markets, plus structural demand from Hyperliquid Strategies, the token offers meaningful diversification benefits.
  • Bottom Line: Regulatory clarity is progressing, but may come with trade-offs that pressure certain business models. The market appears to be penalizing Coinbase more than fundamentals justify, while underappreciating the structural implications of Tether’s audit. In terms of my view on the broader market, not much has changed. The burden of proof remains on the bulls. Stay nimble and maintain dry powder.
Policy Risk & Tether Audit Drive Circle’s Selloff, COIN May Offer Better RV, HYPE Continues to Decouple

Tickers in this video: BTC -0.15% HYPE -0.21% USDC 0.01% COIN CRCL

Disclosures (show)